UK Evaluation Society Framework of Capabilities in Evaluation
Introduction to Guidelines and Framework
Some people identify as evaluators. For others, evaluation is part of a wider role, whether in monitoring, evaluation and learning (MEL), research, analysis, commissioning, consultancy, programme management, policy, HR or another field.
That mix of backgrounds and perspectives is one of evaluation’s strengths. What connects people is not a particular job title, but a shared purpose: using evidence to understand what works, for whom, why and in what circumstances, and using that understanding to help make better decisions.
As evaluation grows in influence, the skills and expectations around it are evolving too. Developing your practice is not simply about gaining more technical knowledge. It is about learning throughout your career, reflecting on your work, exchanging ideas and experience with others, and keeping pace with changes in the field.
Wherever you are in your career, the UK Evaluation Society can help you take the next step. Through professional development, resources, communities and opportunities to connect with others, we support people to strengthen their practice and contribute to the future of evaluation.
Background and context to Guidelines and Framework
Evaluation is becoming more visible, more influential and more important across every sector. In recognition of this, the documents are not set in stone, they will continue to evolve and UKES will continue to take account of feedback, and update on a regular basis going forward, when required.
The framework and guidelines will steer the UKES Centre for Professional Evaluation as they generally provide a coherent and comprehensive approach to both personal development of people who work in or with evaluation, and the multiple dimensions of the evaluation process. Training that delivers against these two will support better evaluation, which is at the core of UKES’ charitable purpose.
Alongside the framework and guidelines, we will introduce additional resources, which may include support for the different roles involved in evaluation (programme leads, evaluators, commissioners, decisionmakers), learning outcomes for non-evaluators, training pathways suitable for different roles and career guidance for early career evaluators. We encourage suggestions as to what could be most helpful to anyone looking to develop their involvement with evaluation. These resources are all intended to support, and not restrict, evaluation and a professional approach to doing it at the best level within the limited resources that most people are working.
UK Evaluation Society
Framework of Evaluation Capabilities
The major purpose of the UK Evaluation Society’s Framework of Evaluation Capabilities is the professional development of evaluators through reflective practice of their knowledge, skills and ability to conduct evaluation.
By focusing on the capabilities evaluators need to demonstrate, the Framework advances evaluation as a social, political and ethical practice. Evaluators may use the capabilities in different ways: to assess where they stand in relation to all capabilities; to explore one or two in depth through a peer review process; to consider what gaps there may be in their evaluation knowledge or skills and what professional development or training they may need to improve their practice.
Introduction
Capabilities constitute the knowledge, skills, and qualities evaluators need to conduct valid, credible evaluation and provide a basis for reflection on their professional practice.
This document is the 2026 revision of the UK Evaluation Society’s Framework of Evaluation Capabilities. The original Framework was published in 2013 and last revised in 2021. This revision, like those which preceded it, builds on the Society’s Guidelines for Good Practice
in Evaluation and is underpinned by the same democratic principles and values: clarity, integrity, equity, diversity, accessibility, independence, trust, transparency.
The five years since the 2021 revision have seen significant change in the landscape of evaluation practice. The rapid emergence of generative artificial intelligence and AI-assisted tools has fundamentally altered what evaluators need to know, and what they can do. The data governance environment has been updated, with the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 joining UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018 as the legislative framework within which UK evaluators operate. Equity and positionality have moved from the margins to the mainstream of evaluation discourse. Communication practice has evolved, with data visualisation, interactive reporting, and accessible digital outputs becoming expected professional competencies.
The 2026 revision responds directly to these developments. It does not dismantle the existing Framework; rather, it updates it to ensure evaluators have the capabilities they need to work with integrity and confidence in the environment they actually face. New capability statements are introduced where genuine gaps exist, and existing statements are revised where their framing has become dated. Statements that remain fully current are carried forward unchanged.
This revision also provides an important foundation for the UK Evaluation Society’s Centre for Professional Evaluation and its developing training programme, including the forthcoming AI in Evaluation course. The Framework is the professional reference point against which training pathways and capability development should be organised and communicated.
Background
In the last two decades, competency frameworks for evaluation have been advanced by an increasing number of professional evaluation societies. Foremost in this movement has been the Canadian Evaluation Society (CES), which developed a set of competencies in 2008–2009 for the purpose of professional designation. The German Evaluation Society DeGEval generated a framework of competencies in 2004 to guide the design of evaluation training programmes. The European Evaluation Society (EES) in 2013 produced a framework of competencies, using the terminology ‘capabilities’, following a survey conducted in 2011 that validated its structure and content.
More recently, AEA (2018), SAMEA, ANZEA, and AES have generated frameworks, as have other organisations with responsibilities for evaluation including the United Nations Evaluation Group (UNEG). A clear zeitgeist of competency generation has taken hold in the professional evaluation community, and the frameworks produced have increasingly reflected not only technical practice but the ethical, social and political dimensions of evaluation work.
The UK Evaluation Society’s Framework sits within this tradition. It has consistently emphasised capabilities in the broadest sense — encompassing knowledge, practice skills, and the personal qualities and dispositions that enable evaluators to function with integrity in complex and contested environments. This 2026 revision maintains that orientation while updating the Framework’s content for a changed landscape.
2026 Revision & Rationale
2026 RevisionThe Framework was last revised in 2021; the 2026 revision responds to significant developments in evaluation practice, technology, and the policy environment since that date. The architectural integrity of the 2021 Framework — its three-domain structure, its principles-based orientation, and its commitment to evaluation as a social, political and ethical practice — has been retained in full.
Changes are concentrated in these areas:
- the addition of new capability statements addressing the commissioning and preparation for evaluation
- new statements addressing artificial intelligence and data governance
- revisions to existing statements to reflect developments in equity, positionality, and digital communication practice;
Explanations for the new and revised statements can be read below, and the document is intentionally aligned with the refresh of the UKES Guidelines for Good Practice in Evaluation.
Artificial Intelligence and Digital Tools
No development since 2021 has more significantly altered the practice environment for evaluators than the emergence of generative AI and large language model tools. Evaluators are now routinely encountering AI tools in their data collection, analysis, synthesis, and reporting work — whether they choose to use them or not, and whether or not the evaluations they are conducting have any explicit AI focus.
The 2021 Framework contains no capability statement directly addressing AI or algorithmic tools. This is now a significant gap. The 2026 revision adds a dedicated capability (1.27) addressing the critical assessment of AI and automated tools in evaluation, and updates the extended statements for data methods capabilities (1.22, 2.15–2.17) to reflect the expanded methodological landscape. This is consistent with UKES’s more focused guidance on AI in Evaluation and provides the capability foundation for the AI in Evaluation training course that is offered by the Centre for Professional Evaluation.
Data Governance
The legislative framework governing data in the UK has evolved since 2021. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 introduced new provisions relevant to data sharing, automated decision-making, and the use of data for research and public interest purposes. Evaluators working with personal or sensitive data — which is most evaluators, most of the time — need to understand this framework and their responsibilities within it.
The 2021 Framework has no explicit capability statement on data governance or data protection. The 2026 revision adds a new capability (2.29) to address this gap, consistent with the data governance updates being made to the UKES Guidelines for Good Practice in Evaluation.
Equity and Positionality
Since 2021, equity (as distinct from equality), positionality, and power dynamics have become considerably more prominent in UK evaluation discourse and practice. Government evaluation guidance, evaluation society frameworks internationally, and leading evaluation practitioners have all increasingly foregrounded the evaluator’s own position and the ways in which it shapes the evaluation process and findings.
The 2021 Framework’s statement on equality, diversity and inclusion (2.25) reflects an earlier framing that does not fully capture this shift. The 2026 revision updates this statement to include explicit reference to positionality and power dynamics.
Digital Communication
The communication competencies required of evaluators have expanded significantly. Data visualisation, interactive and digital reporting, and accessible format design are now expected components of professional evaluation practice. The existing statement (3.1) refers to ‘appropriate language, style and media’ but does not reflect the specificity of current expectations. The extended statement for this capability is updated accordingly.
Professional Development in a Rapidly Changing Field
The pace of change in evaluation practice — methodological, technological, and regulatory — makes continuous and critical engagement with professional development more important than ever. The existing statement on professional development (3.7) is updated to reflect this, emphasising the need to keep pace with emerging methods, tools and technologies as an active professional responsibility.
Commissioning and evaluation preparation
A new sub-group of eight statements have been added at the head of the Professional Practice domain, covering the ground between the decision to evaluate and the start of evaluation design. Each statement is written to read equally well from either side of the commissioning relationship - the commissioner drafting the terms of reference or the evaluator responding to them.
Specific Capabilities
- They are generic. The capability is the same, though how it is demonstrated or applied may differ.
- They are applicable to different social and political contexts, local, national, and international.
- They are not restricted to any particular methodology or evaluation approach and can be adapted to new forms of evaluation and changing areas of practice, including digital and AI-assisted approaches.
- They are designed to be educative, to promote understanding of the capabilities required to conduct quality evaluation and build a culture of evaluation.
Further factors to note:
- The capability statements are not intended to be a comprehensive list that could lead to designation or accreditation. (This purpose has been raised in discussion but the Society has not taken this step or has the resources to institute such a system.)
- Instead the statements offer scope for evaluators to decide which capabilities they need to strengthen.
- It is not expected that individual evaluators will be fully competent in all areas, but should they wish to add to their skills and practice, through self-assessment they can develop their own professional development action plan.
- It is not expected that an individual evaluator will be able to meet all capabilities necessary for any evaluation; at times a team approach will be needed from several evaluators with different capabilities to deliver quality evaluation.
- The Framework may also be used by evaluators new to the field to identify gaps in their knowledge where training would be appropriate.
- There are inevitable overlaps between some statements, as capabilities in different sections interact in practice.
Target Audience
Commissioners of evaluation can reflect on the capabilities they require in an evaluation contract to deliver a quality evaluation and whether these can be met by one person, a team or a partnership between institutions. This is particularly relevant in the context of AI-assisted and data-intensive evaluation, where commissioners may need to understand what capabilities are required to quality-assure novel methodological approaches. Commissioners themselves should give particular attention to a new sub-group of eight statements added at the head of the Professional Practice domain, covering the ground between the decision to evaluate and the start of evaluation design. Each statement is written to read equally well from either side of the commissioning relationship - the commissioner drafting the terms of reference or the evaluator responding to them.
Organisations and evaluation societies can consider building a training programme around capabilities to provide a basis for new evaluators or advanced training for mid-career professional evaluators. The Capabilities Framework can further act as a quality assurance process for participants, managers and stakeholders. For the UK Evaluation Society, our Centre for Professional Evaluation will use as our core training frameworks the capabilities framework alongside our AI guidelines and our general guidelines for good practice in evaluation. Taken together, we think they provide the most comprehensive articulation of what makes an effective evaluator and an effective evaluation.
Scope of the framework
Professional Practice: The capabilities evaluators need to ensure not only that they can conduct a credible, valid evaluation but that they also have the interpersonal, technical, and political skills to manage the process, including if they are commissioning evaluation. These include the ability to work with digital and AI-assisted tools in a principled and critical manner; to navigate complex data governance responsibilities; and to manage the social and political dimensions of evaluation effectively.
Qualities and Dispositions: The personal characteristics that enable evaluators to function in challenging circumstances — to manage conflict, maintain an impartial and independent stance, manage complexity, tolerate ambiguity, and engage in continuous learning in a field that is evolving rapidly.
Framework of Capability Statements
1 EVALUATION KNOWLEDGE
1.11 Identifies the reasons and purpose for which evaluation evolved as a distinct form of inquiry
1.12 Distinguishes the linkages and differences between evaluation and research
1.13 Identifies the political implications of different evaluation theories and their use
1.14 Explores how evaluative thinking influences evaluation practice
1.15 Determines how different policy contexts may influence the design and conduct of evaluation
1.16 Understands the cultural and historical context of the evaluation and its role in driving social change
1.2 Familiarity with evaluation approaches and methodologies
1.20 Understands different types of evaluation and their purpose (formative/summative, developmental/theory based, principle focussed)
1.21 Selects evaluation theories and approaches appropriate for the evaluation task, including participatory approaches
1.22 Assesses advantages and potential constraints of qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods, including digital and data-intensive approaches
1.22a Assesses the suitability of digital data sources, administrative data, online and social media data, and AI-assisted analysis tools for specific evaluation tasks
1.23 Distinguishes different uses of monitoring systems and their role(s) in evaluation
1.25 Identifies how concepts of validity and reliability differ according to method and purpose of the evaluation
1.26 Determines when evaluation requires approaches that can encapsulate and analyse complexity, including systems-level and developmental evaluation
1.27 Critically assesses the use of AI, algorithmic, and automated tools in evaluation, including their implications for validity, bias, transparency, and ethical responsibility
1.28 Considers the different use cases of evaluation and appropriateness of different outputs to ensure maximum utility (e.g., events, communities of practice, presentations, briefings, infographics, slide decks, posters or a report)
2 PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE
3 QUALITIES AND DISPOSITIONS
The UK Evaluation Society would like to thank everyone who contributed their time, expertise and perspectives to the development and review of the guidelines and framework. We are grateful for the thoughtful input from colleagues across the evaluation community, which has helped ensure the guidance is practical, relevant and grounded in evaluation practice.
Disclaimer
This framework is intended to support good practice and professional judgement in evaluation. They provide guidance rather than prescriptive rules and should be applied with consideration for the specific context, purpose and circumstances of each evaluation.
The guidance does not replace relevant legal, regulatory, ethical or organisational requirements, or the need to seek appropriate specialist advice where necessary. The UK Evaluation Society has taken reasonable care to ensure the guidance is accurate and useful at the time of publication. However, practice, technology and regulation continue to evolve, and users are responsible for considering the most current and relevant requirements when applying the guidance.
Who we are
Get in touch
-
learning@evaluation.org.uk
-
Customer service Monday - Friday 9am - 5pm
-
Main website