UK Evaluation Society Guidelines for Good Practice in Evaluation
Introduction to Guidelines and Framework
Some people identify as evaluators. For others, evaluation is part of a wider role, whether in monitoring, evaluation and learning (MEL), research, analysis, commissioning, consultancy, programme management, policy, HR or another field.
That mix of backgrounds and perspectives is one of evaluation’s strengths. What connects people is not a particular job title, but a shared purpose: using evidence to understand what works, for whom, why and in what circumstances, and using that understanding to help make better decisions.
As evaluation grows in influence, the skills and expectations around it are evolving too. Developing your practice is not simply about gaining more technical knowledge. It is about learning throughout your career, reflecting on your work, exchanging ideas and experience with others, and keeping pace with changes in the field.
Wherever you are in your career, the UK Evaluation Society can help you take the next step. Through professional development, resources, communities and opportunities to connect with others, we support people to strengthen their practice and contribute to the future of evaluation.
Background and context to Guidelines and Framework
Evaluation is becoming more visible, more influential and more important across every sector. In recognition of this, the documents are not set in stone, they will continue to evolve and UKES will continue to take account of feedback, and update on a regular basis going forward, when required.
The framework and guidelines will steer the UKES Centre for Professional Evaluation as they generally provide a coherent and comprehensive approach to both personal development of people who work in or with evaluation, and the multiple dimensions of the evaluation process. Training that delivers against these two will support better evaluation, which is at the core of UKES’ charitable purpose.
Alongside the framework and guidelines, we will introduce additional resources, which may include support for the different roles involved in evaluation (programme leads, evaluators, commissioners, decisionmakers), learning outcomes for non-evaluators, training pathways suitable for different roles and career guidance for early career evaluators. We encourage suggestions as to what could be most helpful to anyone looking to develop their involvement with evaluation. These resources are all intended to support, and not restrict, evaluation and a professional approach to doing it at the best level within the limited resources that most people are working.
The principles for good practice in evaluation
The Guidelines are normative, practical statements to facilitate sound evaluation practice in the field. They are informed by the principles set out below.
The Principles
- Clarity: Evaluations should be designed, conducted and reported with a clear purpose that is transparent to all who are part of the evaluation.
- Integrity: The practice of evaluation should demonstrate responsibility to participants according to agreed ethical principles and assure the veracity and validity of the findings, and to populations who are most likely to be affected by the evaluation findings.
- Independence: Evaluations should be independent of vested interests and power differences.
- Accessibility: Findings of evaluations should be available in the public domain and communicable to agreed audiences.
- Trust: No evaluation can effectively proceed without trust, which needs to be developed and nurtured through agreed ethical procedures for conduct and reporting that are fair and just to all.
- Equity: The conduct of evaluation should respect the perspectives and human dignity of all participants and stakeholders, irrespective of their position in professional contexts or social structures, and should be alert to the power dynamics that shape whose perspectives are heard and how.
- Transparency: The principles underlying an evaluation, its approach, ethical practices, limitations and uses should be made explicit to all stakeholders. This includes transparency about the use of artificial intelligence or algorithmic tools in any aspect of the evaluation, the data sources drawn upon, and the role of human judgement in the conclusions reached.
- Diversity: Evaluation should respect cultural, gender and age differences and strive to include all relevant standpoints, including those of the traditionally disenfranchised and marginalised.
For evaluators
How to acknowledge the principles
Evaluators need to acknowledge the principles in evaluation by:
- adopting a code of ethics that is inclusive of all legitimate interests in the evaluation and treats all stakeholders equally and fairly in the evaluation process, reporting and use
- demonstrating commitment to the integrity of the process of evaluation and its purpose to increase learning in the public domain
- making every attempt to minimise harmful effects that may prejudice the status, position, careers or lives of participants
- ensuring the design of the evaluation has paid due attention to equity and diversity
- reflecting on how their own positionality, assumptions and lived experience may shape the evaluation, and taking reasonable steps to mitigate bias through peer challenge, diverse team composition, or external review
- making sure the evaluation team has the capacity and appropriate skills and experience necessary to deliver high quality evaluation
- being mindful that evaluation often has unanticipated effects and consequences
- ensuring the evaluation design and conduct are transparent and fit for purpose and the methodology and procedures are accessible to all relevant stakeholders
- being transparent with commissioners and participants about any use of artificial intelligence or algorithmic tools in the design, conduct, analysis or reporting of the evaluation, and remaining accountable for the judgements reached
- considering the environmental impact of the evaluation approach, including travel, data storage and computational intensity, and taking proportionate steps to minimise this where consistent with evaluation quality
- stipulating that the evaluation is independent of the vested interests of all stakeholders, commissioners and participants, while responsive to issues each might raise relevant to the evaluation, with any potential or perceived conflicts of interest declared and reflected upon in the analysis
- being prepared to argue the case for the public 'right to know' in evaluation
- knowing when to refuse or terminate an evaluation contract
- because it is undoable, self-serving, or threatens to undermine the independence and integrity of the process and outcomes
- negotiating contractual agreement over copyright of evaluation methodology, findings, report and publication.
How to demonstrate the principles
In the planning and conduct of evaluation, evaluators need to demonstrate that they:
- are realistic about what is a feasible, robust methodology to adopt within the time-scale and budget agreed
- conduct detailed planning at the outset of the evaluation
- remain open to revisiting the approach and methodology if changes in policy or field circumstances necessitate
- work within the UK data protection framework and/or any other data protection legislation relevant to the region in which the evalution is taking place (for example, the UK GDPR, the Data Protection Act 2018 as amended, and the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025), or EU GDPR where the evaluation processes personal data of EU residents, to ensure the lawful, fair and secure processing and storage of data
- where using social media, platform, web-scraped or other digital data sources, apply the same ethical standards that would govern primary data collection, including consideration of user expectations, platform terms of service, re-identification risk, and the provisions of the Online Safety Act 2023 where relevant
- where AI tools are used for transcription, coding, synthesis, drafting or analysis, verify outputs against source material, document the tools used and their role, consider implications for data protection and confidentiality, and avoid uploading identifiable or sensitive data to tools without appropriate safeguards (see the UK Evaluation Society companion guidance on AI in Evaluation for further detail)
- acknowledge the intellectual property and work of others
- build outcomes of preliminary discussions with commissioners into the contract yet remain responsive to shifts in purpose and funding
- agree with commissioners a process for managing complaints raised by participants/stakeholders while maintaining confidentiality
- maintain dialogue with commissioners informing them of progress and any changes required to the design and delivery of the evaluation
- follow quality assurance procedures as agreed in the evaluation contract
- consider the usefulness of building external support into the contract (e.g. advisory group or consultant) and/or conditions for quality assurance or arbitration if conflicts cannot be resolved
- include different stakeholder perspectives which, though equally relevant, may be in conflict
- ensure the perspectives of the populations who are directly affected by the evaluation including in particular those less frequently heard are included, by making all methods as accessible as possible.
How to report, communicate and use the principles
In reporting, communicating and use, evaluators need to show that they have:
- agreed a communications policy with commissioners in advance which indicates how the findings will be communicated and the resources required
- assured public access of the evaluation and made every attempt to clear potentially difficult data for public release with those concerned in the context in which it is to be reported
- ensured that evaluation conclusions and implications can be traced to the evidence
- disclosed, in evaluation reports and to commissioners, any material use of AI tools in the analysis or drafting of findings, in a manner proportionate to the role AI played in the conclusions reached
- written and communicated evaluation findings in ways that are useful to all stakeholders by using accessible language, graphics and/or visual presentations
- paid due attention to privacy concerns while at the same time making evaluation knowledge public.
For commissioners
Embedding the principles
▪ are aware of the principles and guidelines that should govern ethical evaluation
▪ ensure that these are adhered to in appropriate evaluation questions, methodology and budgeting
▪ maintain adherence to these principles in the contract and see that they are followed in the conduct and reporting of the evaluation
▪ have realistic expectations of what an evaluation can and cannot provide and agree these with evaluators
▪ hold preliminary consultations with all parties to the evaluation to develop a relevant, realistic and viable specification
▪ design tenders that consider environmental sustainability of the evaluation approach alongside cultural responsiveness, equity and diversity
▪ specify in tender documents their expectations regarding the use of artificial intelligence tools in the evaluation, including any constraints on data processing, disclosure requirements, and expectations for human oversight of AI-assisted outputs
▪ operate a tendering procedure that is open and fair and make explicit the criteria upon which a tender decision will be made
▪ ensure that the tendering process does not exploit competitors' ideas or their intellectual property rights
▪ take into account the advice of evaluators on appropriate fit-for-purpose methods for collecting and analysing data and reaching evaluative judgements
▪ acknowledge the benefits of external, independent evaluation and ensure that evaluators are free to undertake their work as agreed in the contract without any constraints
▪ are open to receiving findings that are unexpected
▪ recognise that negative findings provide opportunities for learning and potential future policy or programme development
▪ recognise and accept where evaluators need to keep their sources of information anonymous.
Planning and conduct of evaluation
- be well versed in the contextual and sometimes conflicting realities of the policies and programmes in action before commissioning an evaluation
- be aware of new and emerging methodologies and the increasing complexity of the contexts in which evaluations have to be conducted
- include experienced evaluators (who are not potential applicants for funding) in initial drafts of evaluation specifications, to inform feasible budgeting and realistic timescales
- specify the context, purpose and audience(s) for the evaluation to encourage relevant tenders
- develop clear and realistic Terms of Reference for the evaluation tender
- include stakeholders in the identification of the core focus and questions an evaluation tender seeks to answer
- ensure sufficient time for evaluators to respond to an initial invitation to tender and produce a proposal
- be open to the inclusion of new methods beyond those specified in the brief where these will better realise the aims of the evaluation
- clarify the constraints they operate under, e.g. timescales, budgets, and deadlines
- provide access to all relevant documentation and data required for the purpose of the evaluation, including administrative data, digital platform data, and any AI or algorithmic systems relevant to the programme being evaluated, subject to appropriate data protection and confidentiality provisions
- adhere to the contract and consult with evaluators and other interest groups if significant changes are required to the design of the evaluation
- communicate openly and keep the evaluation team informed of changes in circumstances or policy affecting the delivery of the evaluation.
In practice, in reporting, communicating and use, commissioners need to consider:
- establishing clear principles for the reporting and communication of evaluations, the resources required and whose role this is, i.e. the commissioners' or evaluators'
- discussing with evaluators, early in the evaluation process, how they wish to receive the findings of the evaluation
- establishing with evaluators the specific criteria for quality work and reporting
- being open to alternative ways of reporting and dissemination that will ensure wide impact and take-up of findings
- respecting the independence of the evaluation by ensuring that it is widely available to all stakeholders and the public
- upholding the independence of the planning and conduct of the evaluation, e.g. not censoring any content of the evaluation or prohibiting its public access
- providing timely and realistic responses to evaluation findings and acting upon them
- preserving the integrity of the findings, e.g. by not quoting or publicising findings out of context.
Practice, reporting, communicating and use
For institutional self-evaluation
Adhering to the principles
- treat all colleagues equally in the process of the evaluation and communication of findings
- ensure the agreement and understanding of all members of the institution before starting the evaluation
- establish methods training for the team conducting the evaluation and ethics training for all staff
- make the purposes, aims, and objectives of the evaluation clear to all members of the institution
- ensure that the process is built into the structure and function of the institution
- make sure all perspectives are included in data collection and analysis
- where AI or algorithmic tools are used in gathering, analysing or interpreting evidence — including staff surveys, performance data or service user feedback — be transparent about their use, consider implications for fairness across different groups, and retain human judgement over the conclusions reached
- demonstrate consistency and predictability of behaviour in the conduct and negotiation of the evaluation
- have the backing and support of the head of the institution, including financial support, where needed, for meetings, networking, communication and publication
- check that all staff know how the process of evaluation will be conducted and how the findings will be used
- involve and co-develop the evaluation with participants throughout the process
- seek out procedures other organisations may have used to guarantee the quality of the self-evaluation, and/or generate any which may be specific to the institution.
Planning and conduct of self-evaluation
During the planning and conduct of institutional self-evaluation, participants need to:
- institute a professional development programme within the institution to help staff develop and build on their capabilities for evaluation
- take steps to ensure that all members of the institution believe the evaluation is worth doing and that, with a clear set of procedures, it has both an internal and external accountability function
- ensure that all involved in the evaluation (whether as data givers, collectors or users) are engaged at some level from the start so they know what is happening and why
- adopt methods that are feasible to use in the time-scales and operations of the institution
- indicate that the process is methodologically sound and one from which valid implications can be drawn
- seek advice and/or consider adopting a critical friend to conduct a process audit of the methodological rigour and fairness with which the evaluation is conducted
- consider any risks that the institution may encounter in the conduct and reporting of the evaluation.
Practice, reporting, communicating and use
- assure members of the institution that the findings from the evaluation are fed back into development as well as providing a measure of accountability
- have a clear set of procedures for the appropriate sharing of data within and beyond the institution
- assure members that data collected for self-evaluation will not be used for any other purpose without their consent
- acknowledge and take steps to reduce any anxiety about the sharing of knowledge within the institution, as this is often more threatening than sharing knowledge with those outside the institution
- recognise and agree when it is important to make data public and when, to encourage development within the institution, it may be necessary to only share the process, not detailed substantive issues
- communicate honestly with colleagues, consistent with maintaining fair and equitable ethical procedures
- communicate in accessible language and engage colleagues in discussion on the usefulness of the evidence and findings.
For evaluation participants
Informing participants
- receiving full information of what participation in the evaluation will mean for them and the relevant data protection processes and rules that will guide the evaluation before seeking consent
- being assured that data will not be gathered or used without fully informed consent and that this may need to be revisited through the evaluation, e.g. rolling or process consent
- being fully informed about the purpose of the evaluation and the procedures for collection and use of data (including explicit use of interview transcripts, observations and image-based data)
- being informed where artificial intelligence tools will be used to process data they provide — including for transcription, translation, coding or analysis — and what this means for confidentiality, accuracy and re-identification risk
- being informed where data about them may be drawn from social media, platforms or other digital sources, and having opportunity to discuss the implications
- establishing clear procedures for the access to and release of data (anonymising identifiable individuals where necessary, but where this is not possible, clearing data with them before public release)
- informing them that the processing of data they offer complies with the UK GDPR, the Data Protection Act 2018 as amended, and the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, and that any data made public is on the grounds of fairness, accuracy and relevance
- having the opportunity to comment on how they are represented in the evaluation to see that this is fair and accurate
- being assured that, in the event of a dispute or difficulties between evaluation participants and evaluators, they will have access to independent arbitration
- knowing that evaluators have taken all reasonable measures to check that the data are valid
- ensuring that any reporting that poses a risk for participants has been discussed and they have had an opportunity to give or withhold consent.
Planning and conduct of evaluation
During the planning and conduct of evaluation, participants will have the opportunity to:
- be engaged in the process of designing, collecting and analysing data if appropriate, as in participatory and co-produced evaluation, and with methods accessible to them
- discuss the basis of and reason for their participation and ask what feedback they will receive
- discuss with evaluators innovative ways of gathering and reporting data about them
- receive training in methods where they are involved in data collection, analysis and reporting
- be assured that every effort will be made to represent all their perspectives in the evaluation
- renew informed consent once more understanding of what the evaluation involves becomes apparent
- have access to the evaluation team for purposes of feedback, reporting and ongoing support for the duration of the evaluation.
Practice, reporting, communicating and use
- have opportunities to comment on the fairness and accuracy with which data they provided has been reported
- be consulted about the form of reporting and its consistency with their data
- know that evaluators will be open to receiving ideas from them about how best to report and communicate findings, including, for example, through digital and social media channels
- be assured that any data they have asked to be kept confidential has been honoured, providing this was not already public knowledge
- be informed that final reports will normally be in the public domain and available to all participants. If there are sound reasons for any exemption from this policy, this and the reasons for it will be recorded.
References to other documents on ethics and evaluation
List of other resources
▪ UK Evaluation Society Guidance on AI in Evaluation and associated resources
▪ UK Evaluation Society Framework of Evaluation Capabilities and associated resources
▪ UK Evaluation Society Centre for Professional Evaluation training resources (forthcoming)
Evaluation ethics codes and principles
▪ Academy of Social Sciences: Generic Ethics Principles in Social Science Research
▪ American Evaluation Association (AEA): Guiding Principles for Evaluators
▪ Australasian Evaluation Society (AES): Guidelines for the Ethical Conduct of Evaluations, and Code of Ethics
▪ Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO, formerly DFID): Ethics principles for research and evaluation
▪ International Development Evaluation Association (IDEAS): Code of Ethics
▪ United Nations Evaluation Group (UNEG): Ethical Guidelines for Evaluation
Research ethics and social media
▪ British Psychological Society: Code of Ethics and Conduct, and supplementary guidance on the use of social media
▪ Social Research Association: Ethical Guidelines
Data protection and AI
▪ Information Commissioner's Office: Guidance on AI and data protection
▪ Information Commissioner's Office: Guide to the UK GDPR
▪ UK Statistics Authority: Guidance on the ethical use of data and AI in statistics and research
▪ Central Digital and Data Office: Guidance on AI use in the public sector
The UK Evaluation Society would like to thank everyone who contributed their time, expertise and perspectives to the development and review of the guidelines and framework. We are grateful for the thoughtful input from colleagues across the evaluation community, which has helped ensure the guidance is practical, relevant and grounded in evaluation practice.
Disclaimer
This framework is intended to support good practice and professional judgement in evaluation. They provide guidance rather than prescriptive rules and should be applied with consideration for the specific context, purpose and circumstances of each evaluation.
The guidance does not replace relevant legal, regulatory, ethical or organisational requirements, or the need to seek appropriate specialist advice where necessary. The UK Evaluation Society has taken reasonable care to ensure the guidance is accurate and useful at the time of publication. However, practice, technology and regulation continue to evolve, and users are responsible for considering the most current and relevant requirements when applying the guidance.
Who we are
Get in touch
-
learning@evaluation.org.uk
-
Customer service Monday - Friday 9am - 5pm
-
Main website